Messi vs Ronaldo · Data & debate

Messi or Ronaldo? Who picked whom

Search sourced opinions from footballers, coaches and public figures. See the question, the reasons given and how answers changed over time.

208Named people
220Sourced statements
195Verdicts and qualified comparisons
25Personal favourites

Each statement records one occasion. Some people gave different answers to different questions. The totals count entries in the archive.

Clear filters

People and statements

208 people 220 statements

Nuno Gomes Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Praised competitiveness and natural talent; expressly acknowledged patriotism influenced his preference.

Context
Pilhado YouTube interview; simultaneously praised Messi and said he would select both in a team.

Link to this person

Olga García Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Natural ability and competitive rivalry with Cristiano Ronaldo helped him surpass everyone.

Context
Joint interview with Alexia Putellas; both choose Messi. Discussion distinguishes Marta in women's football.

Link to this person

Ottmar Hitzfeld Manager Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Gave Ronaldo the edge for that season's goals and Champions League success.

Context
Direct interview as a Laureus Sport for Good ambassador. Explicitly limits answer to that season; calls Pele greatest ever elsewhere in same interview. Page header June 9, interview text dated June 10; month is reliable.

Laureus Primary or official Link to this statement

Link to this person

Ousmane Dembélé Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Sustained outstanding performances and abilities others cannot reproduce; recalled the four-goal Arsenal match.

Context
Report quotes a Sport interview after his Barcelona transfer.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Owen Hargreaves Former footballer / pundit Ronaldo

Link to this person

Paco Alcácer Footballer Messi
Messi Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Makes difficult football actions look easy.

Context
Quote is in Paco Alcácer subsection, despite Iniesta headline.

Link to this person

Paolo Maldini Former footballer Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Regarded Messi as football's essence, uniquely reminiscent of Maradona and the leading player over many years.

Context
Report from Festival dello Sport in Trento; translated paraphrase.

Link to this person

Park Ji-sung Footballer Messi
Messi Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No detailed reason supplied.

Context
Original reporting from his Seoul press conference; called Messi world's best while discussing the upcoming World Cup, not an all-time comparison.

Link to this person

Paul Pogba Footballer Both or no single winner
Both or no single winner Mixed or conditional
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Considered them different players who both give viewers enjoyment, and declined to place one above the other.

Context
Manchester United fan Q&A reported in May 2021. Explicit no-preference response to Messi–Ronaldo comparison. Original club URL was opened but current extraction did not expose the interview text.

Link to this person

Paul Scholes Former footballer and pundit Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Ranked Messi highest among players he shared a pitch with; no technical explanation in this short report.

Context
Reports Scholes's Independent column, explicitly including former teammate Ronaldo among the comparison.

Link to this person

Paulo Dybala Footballer Messi
Messi Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No detailed explanation supplied.

Context
Report reproduces World Cup Instagram statement calling Messi best in world. Later goat emoji is supplementary, not sole evidence.

Link to this person

Pedri Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No technical reason supplied; described being awed when watching Messi train.

Context
Report of an interview with Twitch streamer Ibai Llanos.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Pelé Former footballer · Former player Messi Ronaldo
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Preferred Messi's combination of goals and creating chances.

Context
SporTV interview. Later 2020 answer picks Ronaldo as best at that time; separate dated row.

Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Judged Ronaldo more consistent at that moment.

Context
The March 2020 answer concerns the best player at that moment. Pelé had preferred Messi’s combination of scoring and creating in January 2018.

Link to this person

Pep Guardiola Manager Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Rated Messi higher for combining scoring with creating play for teammates.

Context
Comments ahead of 2016 FIFA Best award; former Barcelona coach.

FIFA Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Pepe Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date

Reason, paraphrased
Emphasised constant improvement and giving his maximum.

Context
Euro 2012 context. Contemporary world-best statement.

Link to this person

Pepe Mel Manager Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Saw Messi as the more complete footballer, while rating Ronaldo the best striker he had watched.

Context
Report of Radio Marca interview.

FIFA Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Piers Morgan Broadcaster · Broadcaster and journalist Ronaldo
Ronaldo All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Argued for success across leagues, goalscoring, aerial ability and using both feet.

Context
Retrospective report explicitly dates these reasons to 2022. These are Morgan's arguments; the database does not endorse every factual comparison he made.

Ronaldo All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No reason available in the retrieved text.

Context
Sky video description confirms the choice. The full spoken reasoning was not transcribed in the retrieved page; a separate 2022 entry records his stated arguments.

Link to this person

Prince William Royal/public figure Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
A narrow choice; no detailed footballing reason stated.

Context
Head-to-head selection game with Tyrone Mings for The Sun. Said the choice was close.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Quique Setién Manager Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Considered Messi's sustained excellence over many years unmatched.

Context
El País interview after leaving Barcelona; GOAT praise despite discussing difficulty managing him.

Link to this person

Radamel Falcao Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No reason stated in cited answer.

Context
El Tiempo interview in the context of the 2013 Ballon d'Or; explicit current comparison with Messi.

Link to this person

Rafael Benítez Manager Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Declared Ronaldo the world's best after his Champions League hat-trick; gave no detailed comparison.

Context
His own Real Madrid player; contemporary best-in-world endorsement, not lifetime GOAT verdict.

UEFA Primary or official Link to this statement

Link to this person

Rafael Nadal Tennis player Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No footballing reason stated in the cited answer.

Context
Fan encounter circulated July 2023. Chose Messi while explicitly noting his Real Madrid support; exact filming date unconfirmed.

Link to this person

Rafael van der Vaart Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Preferred his mentality and success in different settings.

Context
In the Tuttosport interview, he preferred Ronaldo in a comparison with Messi and named Maradona his greatest ever.

Link to this person

Rahul Gandhi Politician Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Considered Messi the better footballer and would select him when building a team.

Context
Separately praised Ronaldo's kindness; did not give a detailed technical rationale.

Link to this person

How to read the archive

Head-to-head picks include quick either-or answers. All-time judgments include answers limited to players the speaker had watched. Best-at-the-time statements apply to the occasion shown.

The publication date can be later than the statement. Sources are labelled as original interviews or official accounts, secondary reporting, or compilations. Some links may require a subscription or limit access.

A conditional answer may lean towards one player. The context records the condition. Personal favourites record preference or fandom.

Latest player updates

News checked

LIONEL MESSI

González backs a free role for Messi against Columbus

AS USA reports that Kily González wants Messi to move freely against Columbus. EFE says the Miami coach has discussed Suárez’s role with the striker.

Our take: Messi scored seven times in nine regular-season appearances under González, including once against Columbus. His goal on the coach’s debut came in the Campeones Cup. Messi’s Inter Miami goal record →Analysis uses records reviewed .

Attributed press conference reporting · team sheet pending

Full report · AS USA · written press conference report

CRISTIANO RONALDO

Ronaldo misses successive Saudi league penalties

Saudi Pro League records show Ronaldo missed against NEOM and Al Ahli, his only penalty attempts in the four league games from one match to the other.

Our take: Across the four league matches from NEOM to Al Ahli, Ronaldo added four goals to his Race to 1,000 tally, all from open play. The Al Kholood hat-trick accounted for three. Race to 1,000 scoring tracker →Analysis uses records reviewed .

Official final match logs · limited league sample

Full report · Saudi Pro League · Al Ahli match commentary

All news and upcoming fixtures →

Was this page useful?

· Tell us what to improve

messivsronaldo.info · The Ultimate GOAT Debate
Stats · FAQs · Records · Honours · Myths · Methodology · Data coverage · Articles · Topics · About · Contact · Vote · Verdict Wall · Privacy · Accessibility
Independently published in the United Kingdom by Daniel R · Not affiliated with either player, their clubs, FIFA or UEFA
Goal statistics carry source and scope notes; editorial ratings are labelled. See the methodology · Corrections welcome via contact