Messi vs Ronaldo · Data & debate

Messi or Ronaldo? Who picked whom

Search sourced opinions from footballers, coaches and public figures. See the question, the reasons given and how answers changed over time.

208Named people
220Sourced statements
195Verdicts and qualified comparisons
25Personal favourites

Each statement records one occasion. Some people gave different answers to different questions. The totals count entries in the archive.

Clear filters

People and statements

208 people 220 statements

Gary Lineker Former footballer and broadcaster Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Placed Messi above other greats; no detailed technical reasoning in this particular quoted answer.

Context
Explicit best-ever endorsement; avoid attributing reporter's editorial explanations as Lineker's words.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Gary Neville Former footballer and pundit Ronaldo
Ronaldo All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Preferred Ronaldo's range of scoring methods, aerial threat and ability to decide matches in different ways.

Context
13 September Monday Night Football debate; former Ronaldo teammate. Verify later statements before treating as latest stance.

Link to this person

Gavi Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No detailed reason supplied.

Context
Quoted during discussion of winning Golden Boy; attributed to Mundo Deportivo. The presently linked MD article did not contain this particular sentence.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Gerardo Martino Manager Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Separated being the best player from winning an award for a particular year's performances.

Context
Speaking as Messi's Barcelona coach after Ronaldo won 2013 Ballon d'Or.

Link to this person

Gheorghe Hagi Former player / manager Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Praised Messi's performances and his example to children.

Context
Contemporaneous best-player comparison; quoted speaking to reporters.

Link to this person

Gianluigi Buffon Former footballer · Former player / goalkeeper Messi Both or no single winner
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Distinguished Ronaldo being best during 2013 from Messi being best across history; no further all-time explanation.

Context
Italia 1 interview. Distinguished Ronaldo as best in 2013 from Messi as best ever. A separate 2025 original interview declines to choose.

Both or no single winner Mixed or conditional
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Declined to rank different roles: Ronaldo the scorer and Messi the playmaker who also scores.

Context
Original interview transcript. This later refusal contrasts with the separately recorded 2014 Messi-best-ever answer.

Link to this person

Giannis Antetokounmpo Basketball player Both or no single winner
Both or no single winner Mixed or conditional
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Called Messi probably the greatest, but chose Ronaldo as the athlete he personally identifies with.

Context
Distinguish sporting-greatness assessment (Messi) from mindset affinity (Ronaldo). Cannot be reduced to one unqualified vote.

Link to this person

Glenn Hoddle Former footballer, manager and pundit Ronaldo
Ronaldo Best at the time
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Cited commitment, powerful running and decisive scoring after the UEFA Super Cup.

Context
Explicitly said Messi had been best two or three years earlier. His all-time selection elsewhere was Maradona.

Link to this person

Gonzalo Higuaín Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No detailed comparative explanation supplied.

Context
Sky Sport interview; occurred before Ronaldo joined Juventus, not a new 2020 statement.

Link to this person

Graeme Souness Former footballer, manager and pundit Ronaldo
Ronaldo Mixed or conditional
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Argued Ronaldo's success across three major leagues strengthened his case after previously leaning Messi.

Context
talkSPORT discussion; argument leans Ronaldo but he explicitly acknowledges previous Messi preference. Not a permanent fixed verdict.

Link to this person

Harry Kane Footballer Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No reason supplied.

Context
Prime Video Sport interview; explicitly compares their peak versions, not total careers.

Link to this person

Harry Maguire Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Personal favourite
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No reason included in the published account.

Context
GOAL attended Manchester United Foundation camp where children asked which of the two he preferred.

GOAL Primary or official Link to this statement

Link to this person

Hristo Stoichkov Former player / manager Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Preferred Messi's technique, intelligence and unselfish team play.

Context
Quotes a Sport Express interview.

GOAL Secondary report Link to this statement

Link to this person

Ian Rush Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Personal favourite
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Preferred his success in three countries, including Italy.

Context
Newspaper’s own interview; explicitly asked favourite between the two, not unrestricted all-time ranking.

Link to this person

Ian Wright Former player / pundit Ronaldo
Ronaldo Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Praised sustained ambition, hard work and success across countries.

Context
Ranking past Ballon d'Or winners, not voting for a single award year. Report cites The Sun; underlying MOTD discussion was May 2020.

Link to this person

Iker Casillas Footballer Ronaldo
Ronaldo Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Cited Ronaldo's seasonal contribution and his firsthand knowledge of Ronaldo's training and ambitions.

Context
Cadena COPE interview, while Ronaldo's Real Madrid teammate.

Link to this person

İlkay Gündoğan Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Decision-making, effective speed, finishing and overall quality.

Context
Explicitly calls Messi greatest of all time, rather than only a favourite.

Link to this person

IShowSpeed Streamer Ronaldo
Ronaldo All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No technical reason stated in this exchange.

Context
Endorsed Ronaldo as the GOAT while reacting to Kevin Durant choosing him. This records Speed's own reported response, not an inference from fan behaviour.

Link to this person

Ishwar Pandey Cricketer Messi
Messi Personal favourite
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
No reason stated.

Context
Favourite-player survey; not a direct superiority question.

BCCI Primary or official Link to this statement

Link to this person

Islam Makhachev Mixed martial artist Ronaldo
Ronaldo Personal favourite
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Said his preference changed after Ronaldo moved to Saudi Arabia and Messi moved to Miami.

Context
Adin Ross interview. Explicitly discusses the person he likes more; this is not a judgment that one is the better footballer. Previously preferred Messi at Barcelona.

Link to this person

Ivan Rakitić Footballer Messi
Messi Head-to-head pick
Statement date
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Calls Messi the sole number one; no technical explanation supplied.

Context
After Villarreal match; explicitly acknowledges Ronaldo as one of history's best.

Link to this person

Jake Humphrey Sports broadcaster Messi

Link to this person

Jamal Musiala Footballer Messi
Messi All-time or best personally seen
Statement date
Unknown
Source publication

Reason, paraphrased
Can do things that other players cannot.

Context
Reports Bayern TV interview; says he cannot personally judge older players he never saw.

Link to this person

James Richardson Sports broadcaster / journalist Messi

Link to this person

How to read the archive

Head-to-head picks include quick either-or answers. All-time judgments include answers limited to players the speaker had watched. Best-at-the-time statements apply to the occasion shown.

The publication date can be later than the statement. Sources are labelled as original interviews or official accounts, secondary reporting, or compilations. Some links may require a subscription or limit access.

A conditional answer may lean towards one player. The context records the condition. Personal favourites record preference or fandom.

Latest player updates

News checked

LIONEL MESSI

González backs a free role for Messi against Columbus

AS USA reports that Kily González wants Messi to move freely against Columbus. EFE says the Miami coach has discussed Suárez’s role with the striker.

Our take: Messi scored seven times in nine regular-season appearances under González, including once against Columbus. His goal on the coach’s debut came in the Campeones Cup. Messi’s Inter Miami goal record →Analysis uses records reviewed .

Attributed press conference reporting · team sheet pending

Full report · AS USA · written press conference report

CRISTIANO RONALDO

Ronaldo misses successive Saudi league penalties

Saudi Pro League records show Ronaldo missed against NEOM and Al Ahli, his only penalty attempts in the four league games from one match to the other.

Our take: Across the four league matches from NEOM to Al Ahli, Ronaldo added four goals to his Race to 1,000 tally, all from open play. The Al Kholood hat-trick accounted for three. Race to 1,000 scoring tracker →Analysis uses records reviewed .

Official final match logs · limited league sample

Full report · Saudi Pro League · Al Ahli match commentary

All news and upcoming fixtures →

Was this page useful?

· Tell us what to improve

messivsronaldo.info · The Ultimate GOAT Debate
Stats · FAQs · Records · Honours · Myths · Methodology · Data coverage · Articles · Topics · About · Contact · Vote · Verdict Wall · Privacy · Accessibility
Independently published in the United Kingdom by Daniel R · Not affiliated with either player, their clubs, FIFA or UEFA
Goal statistics carry source and scope notes; editorial ratings are labelled. See the methodology · Corrections welcome via contact